50 Must-Read 50 Beta
← The Must-Read 50
Cover of Alchemy of Secrets by Stephanie GarberAlchemy of Secrets
New · Fiction, Fantasy, Fairy Tales

Alchemy of Secrets

by Stephanie Garber
2025 · 352 pages · Fiction
Reserve shelf
≈ 9 hours to read · about 3 weeks at 30 minutes a day

What it's about

Holland St. James takes a class in an old movie theater, Folklore 517: Local Legends and Urban Myths. Most students think the Professor's stories are fiction, but Holland has always believed magic is real. When she tracks down a local legend, the Watch Man, who can supposedly tell you when you'll die, her world turns upside down.

Why it's worth reading

It was a Goodreads Choice finalist. It's a romantic, twisty fantasy by the author of Caraval.

You'll love it if you liked

Good to know

It's the first of a series.

By the numbers

54.1Must-Read Score
  • Readers14 out of 100 · counts 42%
  • Critics0 out of 100 · counts 14%
  • Bestseller28 out of 100 · counts 34% (its stronger lane)
  • Buzz0 out of 100 · counts 10%

Critics and Bestseller are two ways to earn a place: a book's stronger one counts more. Buzz rewards recent bestseller weeks and prizes, so older books start at zero. The parts combine into the Must-Read Score, shown on a scale where the best book we found scores 99 and the last book to make the ranking scores 50.

On our reserve shelf: it's well reviewed, but isn't currently a prize winner, a lifetime bestseller or a book everyone's talking about, so we don't rank it. We check again every month, and it can still turn up in your 50 once you've read most of our ranked books.

Why it made the list

Shortlisted
Goodreads Choice (fantasy) finalist (2025)

Reads as

Epic

How we rank

Already read it? Upload your Goodreads or StoryGraph history and get the 50 best books you haven't read, tuned to your taste.Get my 50

More by Stephanie Garber

Cover of Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie GarberOnce Upon a Broken Heart
Once Upon a Broken HeartStephanie Garber
Cover of Caraval by Stephanie GarberCaraval
CaravalStephanie Garber

If you like this, read next

Cover of Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van PeltRemarkably Bright Creatures
Remarkably Bright CreaturesShelby Van Pelt
Cover of Quicksilver by Callie HartQuicksilver
QuicksilverCallie Hart
Cover of Cloud Cuckoo Land by Anthony DoerrCloud Cuckoo Land
Cloud Cuckoo LandAnthony Doerr
Cover of Babel by R. F. KuangBabel
BabelR. F. Kuang
Cover of Lights Out by Navessa AllenLights Out
Lights OutNavessa Allen
Cover of The Book of Form and Emptiness by Ruth OzekiThe Book of Form and Emptiness
The Book of Form and EmptinessRuth Ozeki

Explore the best-of lists

All 36 best-of lists →

Quick answers

Is Alchemy of Secrets worth reading?

It was a Goodreads Choice finalist. Its Must-Read Score is 54.1 (the best book we found scores 99).

What is Alchemy of Secrets about?

Holland St. James takes a class in an old movie theater, Folklore 517: Local Legends and Urban Myths. Most students think the Professor's stories are fiction, but Holland has always believed magic is real. When she tracks down a local legend, the Watch Man, who can supposedly tell you when you'll die, her world turns upside down.

How long does it take to read Alchemy of Secrets?

About 9 hours (352 pages), or about 3 weeks at 30 minutes a day.

What should I read after Alchemy of Secrets?

If you liked it, try Not Quite Dead Yet by Holly Jackson, The Book of Doors by Gareth Brown or The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy by Brigitte Knightley.